Unpaid Overtime: What a Reddit Chef Learned About the Salary Test, the Duties Test, and Getting Paid
A chef with 25 years in restaurants asked r/LaborLaw a question that thousands of salaried workers ask every year. He runs the kitchen at a fine dining restaurant in Washington state as chef and general manager. "I'm in production, hands on in the kitchen 90% of my 70 hour work week," he wrote, with about 10 percent of his time on administrative work. "Salary is 85k in WA state." The title of his post: "Do Chefs pass the duties test for overtime exemption?"
The thread drew a handful of replies, and the best of them pointed at the right question. Whether he is owed unpaid overtime does not turn on the word "salary" or the title "chef/GM." It turns on three tests in federal law, and on what he actually does for 70 hours a week. This guide walks through those tests using his thread, then explains what unpaid overtime is worth and how to claim it.
Do salaried employees get overtime?
Yes, many of them do. The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) requires covered employers to pay nonexempt employees for any "workweek longer than forty hours" at "a rate not less than one and one-half times the regular rate at which he is employed" for the hours past 40 (29 U.S.C. 207(a)(1)). Nothing in that sentence says "hourly." A salary is a way of paying someone, not a waiver of overtime.
The U.S. Department of Labor's Fact Sheet 17A puts it plainly: "Job titles do not determine exempt status." The regulation behind it says the same thing in 29 CFR 541.2: "A job title alone is insufficient to establish the exempt status of an employee." Exempt or nonexempt depends on whether the employee's pay and duties meet the requirements of the Part 541 regulations.
The same fact sheet draws a line that matters for kitchen workers. The exemptions "do not apply to manual laborers or other 'blue-collar' workers," and those workers "are not exempt under the Part 541 regulations no matter how highly paid they might be." Police, firefighters and paramedics are not exempt either, "regardless of rank or pay level." A high salary, by itself, does not take anyone out of the overtime rule.
For the chef, then, $85,000 settles only part of the question. The rest depends on duties.
What are the three tests for an overtime exemption?
The executive, administrative and professional exemptions (the ones employers usually claim for salaried staff) each require three things. An employee who fails any one of them is nonexempt and owed overtime.
- Salary basis. The employee "regularly receives each pay period on a weekly, or less frequent basis, a predetermined amount" that "is not subject to reduction because of variations in the quality or quantity of the work performed" (29 CFR 541.602(a)). An employer that docks a "salaried" worker for a slow night is undermining its own exemption.
- Salary level. The employee must be paid at least the standard salary level. The Labor Department's salary-levels page lists it as "$684 per week (equivalent to a $35,568 annual salary)." Highly compensated employees are tested at "$107,432 per year, including at least $684 per week paid on a salary or fee basis." The page also notes that "these earnings thresholds do not apply to certain types of employees, including doctors, lawyers, teachers, and outside sales employees."
- Duties. The employee's primary duty must match the exemption the employer claims. This is the test most "salaried exempt" workers fail, and it is the one the chef's thread was really about.
The salary level has a history worth knowing, because workers still find older numbers online. A 2024 Labor Department rule would have raised the floor to $844 per week on July 1, 2024 and to $1,128 per week on January 1, 2025. On November 15, 2024, Judge Sean D. Jordan of the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas vacated that rule nationwide, and the threshold returned to $684. On May 15, 2026, the Department issued a final rule formally rescinding the 2024 rule and restoring the 2019 figures. So $684 per week is the federal number today, though many states set a higher one, as Washington does.
What did the Reddit chef thread get right about the duties test?
The first substantive reply came from cervidal2: "Do you make schedules, have hire/fire authority? You're probably exempt if either of those is yes". That is a common shortcut, and it is incomplete. The executive exemption in 29 CFR 541.100, summarized in the Department's Fact Sheet 17B, requires all of the following, not one of them. The employee's "primary duty must be managing the enterprise, or managing a customarily recognized department or subdivision." The employee "must customarily and regularly direct the work of two or more other full-time employees or their equivalent." And the employee "must have the authority to hire or fire other employees, or the employee's suggestions and recommendations" on hiring, firing, advancement and promotion must be given particular weight. Writing the schedule helps the employer's argument. It does not finish it.
MightyMetricBatman took the other route and looked at the learned professional exemption: "Depending on the kind of chef, it is rare, but not impossible to meet the professional exemption". That tracks the regulation closely. Under 29 CFR 541.301(a), the primary duty must be "work requiring advanced knowledge in a field of science or learning customarily acquired by a prolonged course of specialized intellectual instruction." The regulation then speaks to chefs by name in 541.301(e)(6): "Chefs, such as executive chefs and sous chefs, who have attained a four-year specialized academic degree in a culinary arts program, generally meet the duties requirements for the learned professional exemption." Twenty-five years on the line is experience, not a four-year culinary degree, and the regulation's example keys on the degree.
The same commenter added, "10% admin work does not." That is the heart of the duties test. Under 29 CFR 541.700(a), the primary duty is the "principal, main, major or most important duty" the employee performs, judged on the job as a whole. The factors include the relative importance of the exempt duties, the amount of time spent on exempt work, the employee's freedom from direct supervision, and how the employee's pay compares with the nonexempt workers doing similar work. Section 541.700(b) says time is "a useful guide": spending more than 50 percent of the week on exempt work will generally satisfy the test, while an employee who spends less than half the time on exempt work can still qualify if the other factors support that conclusion. There is no hard 50 percent rule, which is why MightyMetricBatman's advice held up: "It really takes talking to a labor attorney to get a better idea of where you fall."
Two other replies were useful for a different reason. MysteriousVehicle wrote, "Here's a real life example of a Chef suing for overtime after being misclassified as exempt:" and linked a federal court docket. Independent_Bite4682 pointed the chef to the Washington Labor and Industries overtime page. Both are the right instinct. A docket shows that misclassified chefs do sue and do get heard; the state page shows that Washington's rules sit on top of the federal ones. Neither tells this chef how his own facts come out. A chef who cooks 90 percent of the week has a strong fact against the executive exemption, but an employer would point to the general manager half of his title, and the answer depends on what that half really involves.
How much is unpaid overtime worth?
Start with one week. The chef's $85,000 salary works out to about $1,634.62 a week. At 70 hours, that is 30 hours past the 40-hour line every week. If he is nonexempt, each of those hours should have been paid at time and one-half of his regular rate. Multiply a week's shortfall by the number of workweeks in the claim period and the figure grows quickly, which is why employers fight the duties test so hard.
Federal law then adds a second layer. Under 29 U.S.C. 216(b), an employer that violates the overtime rule is liable for the "unpaid overtime compensation, as the case may be, and in an additional equal amount as liquidated damages." In plain terms, the statute's starting point is double the unpaid wages. The same section directs the court to "allow a reasonable attorney's fee to be paid by the defendant, and costs of the action," which shifts the cost of a successful case onto the employer. Restaurant wage cases are common enough that TCL has covered them before, including the Din Tai Fung wage theft lawsuit.
The claim period is the other half of the math. Under 29 U.S.C. 255(a), an FLSA suit "may be commenced within two years after the cause of action accrued," or within three years if the violation was willful. Each unpaid workweek is its own claim with its own clock, so waiting a year does not just delay the case. It erases the oldest year of overtime from it.
How do you report unpaid overtime?
You have three routes, and they are not mutually exclusive.
The first is the Labor Department's Wage and Hour Division, which enforces the FLSA. Its complaint line is 1-866-487-9243. The Division's complaint page says that "many investigations are initiated by complaints, which are confidential," and that "an employer cannot retaliate against a worker for exercising their rights." Have your pay stubs, your schedule and your own record of hours ready before you call.
The second is your state labor agency. For the chef that is Washington Labor and Industries, and the state's rules are stricter than the federal ones. Washington's minimum wage rose to "$17.13 an hour" on "Jan. 1, 2026," and the state's news release says that in 2026 "all employers must pay overtime exempt workers at least 2.25 times the minimum wage." That is $1,541.70 a week, or $80,168.40 a year, more than double the federal floor. The chef's $85,000 clears Washington's salary floor by less than $5,000, so his case turns entirely on duties. A Washington chef earning $75,000 would be nonexempt on salary alone, whatever his duties.
The third is a private lawsuit under 216(b), on your own or with coworkers who were classified the same way. Whichever route you choose, the FLSA protects you from payback. Section 215(a)(3) makes it unlawful "to discharge or in any other manner discriminate against any employee because such employee has filed any complaint" or started a proceeding under the Act, and 216(b) lets a court order "employment, reinstatement, promotion, and the payment of wages lost" for a worker who was punished for complaining. If you are fired after raising the issue, TCL's guide on when a firing is actually illegal explains how retaliation claims work alongside the wage claim.
What mistakes cost workers their unpaid overtime?
The first mistake is accepting the label. "You're salaried, so no overtime" is a sentence millions of workers have heard, and for many of them it is wrong. The label is the employer's claim, and the employer has to back it up under all three tests.
The second is keeping no records of your own. Federal law requires employers to keep records of hours and wages (29 U.S.C. 211(c)), but a misclassified employee is often told not to clock in at all. Write your hours down every week, in a notebook or a phone note, with the dates. Keep copies of schedules, texts asking you to come in early, and pay stubs somewhere outside the workplace. In a dispute over hours, a contemporaneous log in the worker's hand carries real weight.
The third is waiting. The two-year clock in 255(a) runs week by week, so every month you wait is a month of overtime you cannot recover.
The fourth is assuming a promotion fixed the problem. Moving a line cook to "kitchen manager" with a small raise and no overtime can cost that worker money if the duties did not change. The regulation says a title is insufficient; the Department says the same in its fact sheet; and the chef's thread shows the question that matters is what fills the week, not what is printed on the schedule.
The fifth is quitting without the final numbers in hand. Leaving the job does not end the claim, but it does make the records harder to get. If you are leaving anyway, request your time and pay records in writing first, and check your state's final-paycheck rules, which TCL covers for California in its final paycheck guide.
The title on the schedule does not decide who gets overtime; the work does, and the records you keep are what prove it.
Frequently asked questions
Can my employer refuse to pay overtime if I am salaried?
Only if you meet every part of an exemption: salary basis, salary level and the duties test. A salary alone does not erase overtime rights, and 29 CFR 541.2 says a job title alone is insufficient to establish exempt status. If any one test fails, hours over 40 must be paid at time and one-half.
How far back can I claim unpaid overtime?
Under 29 U.S.C. 255(a), a federal claim must be filed within two years after each cause of action accrued, or three years for a willful violation. Each unpaid workweek has its own deadline. Some states allow longer look-back periods under their own wage laws.
Can I be fired for filing an overtime complaint?
No. Section 215(a)(3) of the FLSA makes it unlawful to discharge or discriminate against an employee for filing a complaint, and 216(b) allows a court to order reinstatement and lost wages. The Wage and Hour Division also treats complaints as confidential.
Does Washington set a higher salary threshold than federal law?
Yes. For 2026, Washington requires overtime-exempt workers to earn at least 2.25 times the state minimum wage of $17.13 an hour, which is $1,541.70 a week or $80,168.40 a year, against the federal floor of $684 a week. The duties test still applies on top of the salary test.
Sources
- U.S. Department of Labor, Fact Sheet #17A: Exemption for Executive, Administrative, Professional, Computer and Outside Sales Employees
- U.S. Department of Labor, Fact Sheet #17B: Exemption for Executive Employees
- U.S. Department of Labor, Overtime salary levels
- U.S. Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division, How to file a complaint
- 29 U.S.C. 207, Maximum hours (Cornell LII)
- 29 U.S.C. 215, Prohibited acts (Cornell LII)
- 29 U.S.C. 216, Penalties (Cornell LII)
- 29 U.S.C. 255, Statute of limitations (Cornell LII)
- 29 CFR 541.2, Job titles insufficient (Cornell LII)
- 29 CFR 541.301, Learned professionals (Cornell LII)
- 29 CFR 541.602, Salary basis (Cornell LII)
- 29 CFR 541.700, Primary duty (Cornell LII)
- Washington Department of Labor and Industries, Washington's minimum wage going up to $17.13 an hour in 2026
- Foley Hoag, Texas Federal Court Nullifies DOL's Final Rule on Federal Overtime Exemptions (Nov. 22, 2024)
- Proskauer, Law and the Workplace, DOL Makes It Official: 2024 Overtime Rule Is Gone (May 14, 2026)
- r/LaborLaw, Do Chefs pass the duties test for overtime exemption?
This article is general legal information about overtime pay and wage claims, not legal advice. Exemption rules, salary thresholds and filing deadlines can depend on your state and your situation. For advice on your situation, contact an employment attorney or legal aid office licensed in your state.
Featured image: photo by Pylyp Sukhenko on Unsplash.